Forum

This is more of a test than anything.

I've been working on Neil's way to play 'Blackbird'-- using my thumb as an alternating bass. Trouble is, before TG, I had originally learned how to play it using my index finger to constantly play the G string. It has been tough to unlearn that muscle memory, but it's coming along.

I thought I'd put up a quick comparison of the two ways of playing it, as this has also been asked a few times in the forums... "Why can't I play 'Blackbird' using my index finger?"

I don't remember Neil's exact answer, but I think NOT using your index finger actually gives a more consistent sound with the alternating bass notes.

I think the thumb sounds better as well. Let me know what you think.

Good to see I am not the only practicing tonight! I find that using the thumb to alternate bass, gives a more equal sound to the bass.

Great demo, love your transition animation

Marc

Edit: and I would add that this is a good exercise for the thumb

It sounds smoother and richer (less tinny) with the thumb. It sounds good Al.

Thanks for checking it out Marc and Michele.

I agree that it sounds more equal and less tinny without my index finger.

Good job Al. You know, that 'Hogan guy' is right about a lot of things concerning the guitar. Congratulations on your transition to the 'right' way.



Bill

The alternating thumb version definitely sounds better.

David

Hi Al,,now is the point for me that i love it in many way's,, you did great..hope that Neil gives us a awnser on the use with alternating thumb,,

ps like Marc i like the vid transition,,can we do that in WMM.??

Definitely more thumb!!

Thanks Bill, David, Chas & Willem.

I was frustrated at first, thinking- "I already (kinda) know the song! Why bother UNlearning it and learning it AGAIN?!"
I think the answer is in the video- even though it is subtle. I will do a full song upload soon.

BTW Willem- the transition is from AVS. Unfortunately I think that's the program that you couldn't get to work on your computer.

Hello Al.

Nice to see you here with this fantastic tune.
I think that the second is bether,i agree whit Marc.
Not easy to learn off how to play this tune.
Thanks fore share your great video.

greetz Anton