Actually, maybe I've been WAAAAAAAY too quick to treat it as one that I should re-home. And maybe it was the gusto indeed (producing the rattle). Maybe it's just settling into the new strings and being under tension again...I have no idea. But, this evening it is sounds much better and the strings feel OK. Haha!
But, I'm up for an experiment I think. So I think I might just change the 1st, 2nd and 6th to the medium gauge strings as Doug suggested for DADGAD tuning and see what that's like.
The neck width is something I'm needing to adjust to as I've been playing my nylon mostly with it's whopping classical neck.
Life's too short you say. Hopefully that's not because I don't have much left.
I probably will still find someone who needs this guitar more than me. But I'm having fun exploring it in the meantime.
Shel